About Us

Ever since 1988, Anthony's Pizza has been greeting customers in Casselberry, Florida, with hearty and delicious pizza. Our authentic brick-oven pizzas were inspired by our great love of food, and we love being able to share these great creations with you.

Only the Freshest Ingredients From the very beginning, we made a decision never to compromise the quality of our pizzas, and over the years, we have kept true to that. This means that we only use the finest and freshest ingredients, special seasonings, and pizza dough that is made here every day. The cheese we use is made by the Grande Cheese Company™, which is known as "The Best Italian Cheese Money Can Buy." We shred it by hand for the best mixture of flavors. Our flavorful sauces are prepared with plump, fresh, Italian tomatoes with fresh vegetables and no canned mushrooms or peppers. Each meatball and sausage is made according to an old family recipe that has become a local favorite.

True Italian Authenticity

From the very first moment when you walk into Anthony's, you notice the smell of garlic and basil, telling you that this is an authentic and quality pizza place. You'll see our showcase, fully stocked with our freshly made pizza according to true New York Italian styles. Choose from pizzas that include our exclusive V.I.P Pizza, our addicting Spinach and Tomato Pizza, the Pizza Bianca, and even a perfectly made Sicilian Pizza.

Long-Standing Reputation

Over the years, we have made lots of friends in our community who keep coming back over and over. Because we don't take shortcuts on our way to excellence, you know that you are getting the best pizzas that can be made. We take great pride in the tradition of making fine, authentic Italian pizza.

Our chef has been here for more than 20 years, and much of our staff has been with us for more than 10 years. Not only that, but even our dough is aged to perfection on a cured stone to give you the perfect flavors.